In his excellent op ed, “Dishonor, war, or both?” (September 27), Ben Cohen concludes with a quote from Churchill to Chamberlain after the Munich Pact: “You were given the choice between war and dishonor. You chose dishonor, and you shall have war.”
What Churchill did not say is that the war he predicted was a more devastating war with much greater loss of lives, than if Chamberlain had chosen to stop Hitler initially. We must recognize that there are times when war saves lives.
The same situation exists with Iran. We all want a true diplomatic solution. We hope and pray that our leaders, unlike Chamberlain, can realize when they are being duped. If Iran successfully uses diplomacy as a delaying tactic to develop nuclear weapons, we will all pay dearly. Stopping a nuclear armed Iran will be a much more costly war in every aspect than if we do it now. A “peace in our time” diplomatic solution is not a solution. We should learn from history.
I am generally an admirer of Rabbi Boteach, and respect his opinions. However, I was disappointed to read his October 4 op ed, “President Obama’s astonishing overtures to a terror state.”
I understand that Iran is a threat to Israel and to the United States, and the rhetoric coming from that country gives little assurance of peaceful intent.
President Obama has proven that he is a friend of Israel and that he will not shrink from making difficult choices when it comes to selective use of our armed forces. It is insulting to the president and to the overwhelming percentage of American Jews who voted for him to accuse Obama of being blind, gullible, or in some manner “soft” on Iran.
Rabbi Boteach calls Iran a “terror state,” and he is correct. If press reports are to be believed, Iran is also a troublemaker in the region. The sanctions Obama has put in place have hurt Iran and probably convinced it that the United States is serious about its need to curtail the weapons program. Most reasonable people would agree that it is the sanctions that have brought the Iranian leaders to contemplate changes in their policies.
Talking to friends is easy. Talking to enemies takes courage. Bombing is also easy, but its unintended consequences could prove very dangerous to the Jewish state.
I have every reason to believe that Obama is no pushover and will maintain sanctions until Iran, by deeds and not words, shows that, for whatever reasons, it will respect international norms and treaties. Let’s give time-limited negotiations a chance.
I was pleased to see the positive review of the Yiddish “Waiting for Godot” at Manhattan’s Castillo Theater (September 27). We already have tickets and are very much looking forward to seeing it. I would just add a few corrections:
The Yiddish title of the play is “Vartn af Godot.” In the review, the Yiddish title is incorrectly rendered as “Varten far Godot,” which actually means “Waiting in front of Godot” — clearly not the intended translation.
Omitted from the review is the fact that English and Russian supertitles are provided; therefore, you don’t have to speak a word of Yiddish to attend, understand, and appreciate this unique version of the classic play.
Rabbi Shmuley Boteach praised Sheldon Adelson in his recent column, which mentioned an event on genocide where Adelson gave the introductory remarks (“As money grows, rabbis shrivel,” September 20.)
It is unfathomable how a man like Adelson can be honored this way, when his bully-pulpit newspaper Israel Hayom consistently incites xenophobia against African asylum seekers in Israel, including those fleeing genocide in Darfur.
Adelson’s newspaper runs story after story labeling Sudanese and Eritrean asylum seekers as “illegal infiltrators” and “economic migrants.” Israel Hayom sensationally stokes hate with blanket portrayals of Africans as a violent criminal element.
The Adelson/Boteach event on genocide at Cooper Union in New York on September 29 was subtitled: “Do the Strong Have a Responsibility to Protect the Weak?” The answer to that question, both from a human rights perspective and from a Jewish perspective, is a definitive yes.
As party to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol, Israel must stop returning refugees to dangerous situations without allowing them to have their legal claim for asylum heard and evaluated. Within Jewish scripture, one of the most repeated Jewish commandments is to care for gerim, the landless sojourners who seek refuge among us.
If Rabbi Boteach is serious about genocide, he should call out Adelson for his insidious rhetorical role in the mistreatment of African asylum-seekers in Israel who have fled genocide and other atrocities.
Director of Israel Programs, T’ruah: The Rabbinic Call for Human Rights
New York, N.Y.
Shmuley Boteach responds:
Sheldon Adelson is the largest single donor to Yad Vashem and countless Holocaust educational programs worldwide. As someone who has contributed $200 million to Birthright alone — with its mandatory visits to Yad Vashem — Mr. Adelson has arguably exposed more young Jews to the Holocaust than anyone else.
Now the Adelsons have partnered with me in ensuring the world properly commemorates the Rwandan genocide, sponsoring the event I organized this past Sunday that attracted over 1,000 people, and brought together, for the first time, Elie Wiesel and Rwandan President Paul Kagame.
Every country makes a distinction between asylum seekers and economic immigrants. Israel must of course do its utmost to welcome those fleeing genocide and murder, and I personally discussed with Prime Minister Netanyahu allowing 5,000 Syrian refugees into Israel.
Approximately 70,000 Eritrean and Sudanese citizens took advantage of what was an open border between Israel and Egypt, and crossed into Israel. The Israeli Refugee Status Determination Committee checked thousands of cases and apparently found a minority to be asylum seekers, with the others registered as economic migrants. While I wholeheartedly agree that Israel should open its doors to those fleeing genocide, illegal immigration on the part of workers remains as controversial in Israel as it is here in the United States, and will continue to be debated by Israel’s citizens and publications.
Bergen County is fortunate in that the former Mayor of Paramus, James Tedesco III, is running for freeholder on November 5. He is leaving a tremendous legacy in Paramus.
The Generelli Sports Plaza, affordable housing near the major shopping mall in Paramus, and Bocci Court at the Senior Center, with new chairs, new rugs and up-to-date kitchen for the 21st century. The July 4th parade which Gov. Jon Corzine attended each year during his governorship, updating and repairing the band box at the library, with concerts every week during the month of August, the mayor’s luncheon at the Electric Union Hall, upgrading the Paramus golf course with champion competition, a kiddy golf course and putting green; upgrading Paramus pool for all Paramus residents, and ticket purchase possible for surrounding neighbors, computers available at the Senior Center and library for every one to use.
A few years ago there was a concerted effort to eliminate the blue laws. His famous words, “over my dead body,” put a quick stop to this silly and foolish attempt.
He was born and grew up in Bergen County, and I believe he is familiar with every street and legislator in Bergen County. He can bring his forward-looking determination, expertise, and experience to the Freeholders Board.
Respectfully, I urge my friends, Democrats, Republicans, and Independents, to elect James Tedesco III to the Board of Bergen County Freeholders.
We at Moishe House Hoboken would like to thank the area organized and local Jewish community for funding and supporting MH Hoboken.
Moishe House Hoboken was founded in January 2007 and has been creating unique Jewish programs for young adults from all parts of New Jersey. While the majority of MH Hoboken’s programming has been in Hoboken, community members originally hail from all over New Jersey. From Fair Lawn to Florham Park, Bergenfield to Bloomfield, Millburn to Mahwah, Elizabeth to Englewood, our community members are sons and daughters of New Jersey’s Jewish community (with a few transplants to our great state and NYCers mixed in).
From the early days, we have been able to grow by working with local stakeholders and an amazing cadre of participants, and that quickly became an ever-growing community. From the on-the-ground Jewish presence, the United Synagogue of Hoboken, to the Jewish federations of Northern New Jersey and Metro West, we have had amazing institutional partners. We have been proud to work with the federations and USH on joint programs, from celebrating Yom Haatzma-ut to working with the federation shlichim (emissaries from Israel), from having spiritual salons facilitated by the USH rabbinic interns to volunteering on Super Sundays.
When, on April 26 this year, the Jewish Standard printed a piece on MH Hoboken’s potential closing (“Closing down the House?), these local stakeholders, as well as the Leo Rosner Foundation, the independent UJA Campaign of Hoboken/JFNA Network of Independent Communities, and the Maimonides Fund, decided to invest in young adults. For USH, itself the only outpost of shul life in a region not known for well established Jewish community and for the Northern New Jersey and MetroWest federations, whose catchment areas do not extend to Hoboken, to come to our aid speaks volumes about their commitment to a bright Jewish future.
Just as importantly, many of our Moishe House community members answered the call for monetary support and deepened their investment in organized Jewish life. We recently honored our local community donors at our first annual MH Hoboken gala.
New Jersey’s young adults come and live in Hoboken and Jersey City. At MH Hoboken they are stakeholders in a vibrant community that offers home cooked (or sometimes catered) Shabbat meals, celebrations of the chaggim, interesting Jewish speakers and more. We in MH Hoboken, both community members and residents, thank the New Jersey Jewish community for continuing to support us as we pioneer and build a Jewish young adult community.
Founder, former resident
Stephanie Goodman, Stephanie Premeslaar
Residents, Moishe House, Hoboken
Most Americans have forgotten (“Striking at Syria,” September 13). Assad used gas against children and women and men. It reminds me of actions Adolf Hitler took against Jews. We all know the hate Syrians and Iran have for us Jews.
This connection between Assad and Hitler is never brought up in the media. Why are Jews silent about this ? The use of gas cannot be tolerated. Assad must be brought to justice. God protect Israel ! God bless America !
Maggie Seidel, Rep. Scott Garrett’s (R-N.J. 5th Dist.) communications director, took strong exception to our describing the Constitution Caucus as conservative in “Striking at Syria” (September 13). She says that it is merely a caucus, that it once had a Democratic member, Rep. Bobby Scott of Virginia, who left it over a Obamacare, and that it is open to all.
We stand by our reporting.
In response to Shammai Englemayer’s September 13 column (“My children are dying): Enough with the bleeding hearts.
None of us want to see war. We don’t want anyone to be gassed and the use of chemical weapons by Assad earns him the death penalty. But the Torah predicted that the warlike and murderous people who inhabit the Middle East would have “their hand against everyone,” including each other.
At the moment, they are killing each other in Libya, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and who knows where else. These are the same people who murder their daughters who have had the misfortune of getting raped. These are the people who rejoice when a suicide bomber goes into a Jerusalem pizza store and kills innocent men, women, children and infants. These are people who have killed and maimed so many of our soldiers. These are the same people who stood across the river from the collapsing World Trade Center towers and danced and congratulated the perpetrators.
Yes, God does not want levity and singing when his children are dying, but he is the same God who demands that we eradicate evil. If it wants to eradicate itself, even better.