Subscribe to The Jewish Standard free weekly newsletter


entries tagged with: David Seth Kirschner


Local rabbis sign on to new centrist pro-Israel group

Rabbis for Israel offers option between AIPAC and J Street

A new pro-Israel organization that aims to give rabbis a middle ground between AIPAC and J Street has the attention of several local rabbis.

Rabbis for Israel, launched last month by Rabbi Michael Boyden of Hod Hasharon, Israel, bills itself as a centrist group dedicated to a two-state solution with peace and security for Israel. More than 230 rabbis, including six from Northern New Jersey, have signed on to the group’s mission statement.

“I was amazed that so many leading rabbis from all streams and from all over the world, including North America, Israel, and Europe, should have chosen to identify with Rabbis for Israel in such a short space of time,” Boyden said in a statement. “The response shows the degree to which many Jewish leaders are thirsty for an advocacy group that represents the middle ground in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.”

Rabbi Jonathan Woll, of the Progressive Havura of Northern New Jersey in Glen Rock, met Boyden during a visit by the Israeli rabbi to Woll’s now-defunct Temple Avoda in Fair Lawn. When Woll heard of Boyden’s group, he quickly signed on because of its centrist position.

Woll had been an early supporter of J Street, which hailed itself as pro-Israel and pro-peace, but he became disappointed with it.

“When we came to the flotilla incident,” and J Street’s swift condemnation of Israel, “my disappointment … really gave way to some kind of uncertainty in their position,” he said. “I do respect [J Street founder] Mr. [Jeremy] Ben-Ami. I think he’s a highly intelligent individual. His positions are not for the most part untenable.”

Who’s signed on?

Rabbi Bruce Block, Tenafly
Rabbi Neal Borovitz, Temple
Avodat Shalom, River Edge
Rabbi Ken Emert, Temple Beth
Rishon, Wyckoff
Rabbi Debra Hachen, Temple
Beth El of Northern Valley,
Rabbi David-Seth Kirshner,
Temple Emanu-El, Closter
Rabbi Jonathan Woll, Progressive
Havura of Northern New Jersey,
Glen Rock


Rabbi Neal Borovitz of Temple Avodat Shalom in River Edge echoed Woll’s disappointment with J Street, which, he said, wrongly equates equality with equity, assigning equal blame to Israel and the Palestinians.

“They’re looking at it to a certain degree through a colored lens that doesn’t let them see the reality of where the Middle East peace process has gone over the 33 years since [the late Egyptian President Anwar] Sadat came to Jerusalem,” he said.

Borovitz, chair of the Jewish Community Relations Council of UJA Federation of Northern New Jersey, didn’t shy away from criticizing AIPAC either.

“AIPAC has taken an unrealistic view of the Middle East peace process that is far too hardline for me on issues of the territories and settlements and defending what I think are indefensible actions,” he said. “Both of these very vocal pro-Israel lobbies — and I believe J Street is pro-Israel as well — have found themselves caught up in both American and Israeli partisan politics and are failing to represent a moderate centrist voice that is critically supportive of Israel.”

Disagreeing with specific Israeli policies or actions does not negate overall support of the Jewish state, said Temple Emanu-El of Closter’s Rabbi David-Seth Kirshner, who recently returned from three and half weeks in Israel.

He pointed to the recent flap over Arizona’s immigration law. Just because he disagrees with the law does not mean that he will not visit Arizona or stop loving America, he said. Similarly, American Jews need to be able to equally express criticism of Israel without abandoning support of the Jewish state.

“We can be a liberal and love and support Israel and we can be a conservative and love and support Israel,” he said. “It should be something that is part of the core of every Jewish person — even those secular and non-Jewish people who can appreciate what Israel brings to the world.”

For the complete statement, go to


Israel is your country, too

Knesset member Dalia Itzik brings messages of peace, unity to Solomon Schechter in New Milford

Dalia Itzik, head of the Kadima faction in Israel’s Knesset, addressed students and community members at Solomon Schechter Day School in New Milford on Tuesday. SSDS/Rachel Banai

Dalia Itzik, Israel’s first female speaker of the Knesset, brought a message of peace to New Milford’s Solomon Schechter Day School on Tuesday as she addressed community leaders and students.

“We need you as our friends, we need you as our partners,” the former Knesset speaker said to a group of rabbis and community leaders. “We need you to continue your longtime support of Israel.”

Itzik’s visit was sponsored by Israel Bonds and coordinated by Rabbi David-Seth Kirshner of Temple Emanu-El in Closter. He praised Schechter’s plurality and told The Jewish Standard, “She’s going to see some of the plurality we hope for in Israel.”

Itzik first addressed a group of rabbis and school officials, updating them on events in Israel and the peace process and Iran. Last year’s Operation Defensive Shield was a response to a constant barrage of rockets from Hamas and eight years of restraint by Israel, she said. She labeled those who criticized Israel during the operation as hypocrites, and dismissed the notion that Hezbollah and Hamas are fighting for land.

“They’re not fighting over borders. They’re not fighting over agreements,” Itzik said. “The real conflict is with our values, the values we share with you and the free world. The rest is just an excuse.”

Extremists are also a threat to the Palestinians, so reaching “a clear and viable solution” is a common interest, she said. Itzik warned that Iran will be a danger to Israel and the entire West if it attains nuclear weapons.

“Bitter experience has taught us to take such madmen [as Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad] seriously,” she said. “The ruler of Iran denies the Holocaust and has made us his target.”

After a performance of “Havenu Shalom Aleichem” by the first-grade class, Itzik moved from one room to another to address the school’s sixth-, seventh-, and eighth-grades. She began by asking how many students understood Hebrew. The majority raised their hands. She then asked how many planned to visit Israel during Pesach. Again, the majority raised their hands. But when she asked how many wanted to be members of the Knesset, not a single hand went up, which drew a few chuckles.

Itzik then took a few questions from students, which they asked in Hebrew and then in English.

“Israel is your country, too,” she said. “I am very, very proud we have a country. With your help and your parents’ help, it will be a better place.”

Every day Israelis greet each other with “shalom” or “mah shlomcha,” how are you, which comes from the same root as shalom, she said.

“I don’t know any country in the world that dreams of peace [more than Israel],” she told the children.

Speaking to the Standard afterward, Itzik said the number of Israelis and diaspora Jews who never knew a world without Israel is growing, and they need to understand their responsibilities to help the state, just as the founding generation built Israel. Even her own children, now grown, she said, don’t understand what a miracle the Jewish state is, and that Israel still needs to fight for its existence.

That Israel is a democracy is another miracle, she said, considering that so many of the first wave of immigrants came from non-democratic countries in the Arab world.

“It’s very important for the young generation that they understand, that they continue what we started,” she said.

The 10-month settlement freeze, which Itzik did not support, was a major gesture to the Palestinians, which they should appreciate, she said. She does not support extending the freeze, but she and her Kadima Party support continued negotiations. Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran, and other extremist elements in the region do not threaten only Israel, and the Palestinians should recognize that, she continued.

“When you talk with moderate Palestinians, Jordanians, Egyptians, they understand we are in the same boat,” she said. The extremists “have adopted violence as a way of life,” she continued. “Since we’re in the same boat, [the moderate Arab governments] understand they must make concessions [in negotiations with Israel].”

Peace is the ultimate goal, she said.

“We want peace. This is our dream,” she said. “We have to convince the international community [that the terrorists] fight against what we represent — democracy, human rights, women’s rights, values.”

Itzik, who began her career as a teacher, is a former deputy mayor of Jerusalem in charge of education. She was elected to the Knesset in 1992 as a member of the Labor Party, and has served as minister of the environment, minister of industry and trade, and minister of communications. In 2006, she left Labor for former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s fledgling Kadima. Later that year, she was appointed speaker of the Knesset, a position she served in until 2009. During that time, she twice served as acting president of Israel.

“It was such an amazing match for her to see the kind of young leaders we raise, the level they care for the State of Israel,” said Ruth Gafni, SSDS head of school. “I was very touched by her commitment to support the peace process despite the difference in the parties.”

Especially for the school’s female students, Itzik is an example of what women can accomplish, Gafni said.

“It’s a wonderful fit,” said Gafni. “For the children, Dalia Itzik is a perfect role model.”

Page 1 of 1 pages
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31