Subscribe to The Jewish Standard free weekly newsletter


entries tagged with: Aryeh Eldad


Flotilla raid stokes debate on price of Gaza blockade

Dina KraftWorld
Published: 04 June 2010

ASHDOD, Israel – The blurry black-and-white video footage was not what any Israeli wanted to see: elite navy commandos armed with paint balls (the pistols were only to be used as a last resort) dangling by a rope onto a boat filled with activists wielding metal bars and knives.

In one scene, an Israeli commando is thrown to the deck below by the mob aboard the ship.

“It’s not just appalling footage, it’s a national humiliation and a blow to Israel’s deterrence,” military analyst Amos Harel wrote in the Israeli daily Haaretz a day after the deadly confrontation between Israeli commandos and pro-Palestinian activists aboard the Gaza-bound ship that left nine activists dead. “The question is why the soldiers were put in this situation in the first place.”

An Israeli student brandishes her identity card in a June 1 demonstration outside Jerusalem’s Hebrew University in support of the Israeli navy raid on ships bound for Gaza. Kobi Gideon/Flash 90/JTA

As Israeli officialdom begins the process of reckoning — the navy is expected to conduct an inquiry and there have been calls for Defense Minister Ehud Barak to resign — analysts tried to untangle the strategy behind the botched raid on the Free Gaza movement flotilla. Many in the Israeli media are describing the raid as an intelligence, operational, and political failure.

The massive diplomatic fallout triggered by the flotilla confrontation also has ratcheted up the debate in Israel over the efficacy of Israel’s policy of blockading Gaza.

“Three years of a failed strategy brought us to the events of today,” said Yossi Alpher, co-editor of, an Israeli-Palestinian Website. “We could have dealt with this differently had we thought better strategically in advance about the consequences of our failed strategy in Gaza.”

Military sources said that although the commandos knew a confrontation was possible on the ship they boarded, the Mavi Marmara, they were surprised by the attempts to kill Israeli troops.

Despite the violent result of the raid, government officials said Israel had little choice but to find some way to confront and halt the six-ship flotilla because of the risk that there could be weapons in the uninspected cargo that could reach Hamas, the terrorist group that rules the Gaza Strip.

“This is the ninth effort to get boats into Gaza,” said Andy David, a spokesman for the Israeli Foreign Ministry. “The first three were allowed through, but then we began to see it was becoming like a leaking faucet we had to put an end to because, as we have seen, Hamas is doing all it can do in its power to smuggle in weapons.”

David added, “If they had wanted to really deliver humanitarian aid, they could have done it through the Ashdod port.”

Passengers aboard the ships, however, said they did not trust that Israel — which has enforced a three-year blockade of Gaza, since Hamas militants wrested control of the territory from the Fatah-led Palestinian Authority in a bloody coup — to deliver the aid.

The government also was wary about who was on board the ships, Israel Defense Forces spokeswoman Maj. Avital Leibovich told reporters during a briefing overlooking the Ashdod port as the ships in the flotilla were brought in for inspection Monday.

“You don’t know who is on board such ships and whether they might be a security threat or not,” she said.

Above all, the government appeared eager to make an example of this six-ship flotilla — the largest effort to date to break the blockade of Gaza — to show the world that it would not tolerate efforts to break the blockage, international condemnation notwithstanding.

The government made it very clear that it was not going to allow the passage of these ships and, in turn, wrote veteran commentator Nahum Barnea in Yediot Achronot, “committed itself, for all intents and purposes, to a confrontation.”

Some Israelis are saying the strategy was a mistake, that it would have been better to ignore the ships rather than give more fodder to pro-Palestinian activists trying to mobilize anti-Israel and anti-blockade sentiment.

“If the siege had any international legitimacy, today it lost a great deal of it,” said Meir Javedanfar, an independent political analyst. “Yes, Israeli citizens have a right to live in peace, but they have to find other ways of doing it. The siege hurts Israel more than Hamas because of the political costs it pays in terms of isolation, the damage of its relations with its allies and Europe, and how it helps demonize Israel.”

The blockade on Gaza has been a public relations burden for Israel ever since it began three years ago in an effort to isolate and weaken Gaza’s Hamas rulers, help bring home captured soldier Gilad Shalit, end Hamas rocket fire on Israel, and halt the flow of weapons into Gaza.

Though when it began the blockade had the backing of the United States, Egypt, and even the Palestinian Authority, it has been criticized as collective punishment for Gaza’s population. Even in Israel, some have called it a policy failure, complaining that the overly strict siege has blocked even legitimate humanitarian and civilian materials from reaching Gaza’s residents.

After Monday’s incident, the U.N. special coordinator for the Middle East peace process, Robert Serry, and the commissioner general of the U.N. Relief and Works Agency, Filippo Grandi, issued a joint statement scolding Israel.

“We wish to make clear that such tragedies are entirely avoidable if Israel heeds the repeated calls of the international community to end its counterproductive and unacceptable blockade of Gaza,” the statement said.

But proponents of the strategy for dealing with the flotilla and of the blockade itself said that allowing the ships to pass would have opened a new access route for Iran to send rockets to the strip.

“If there was no siege at all, they can bring whatever boats they want,” Israeli lawmaker Aryeh Eldad of the National Union Party told JTA in a telephone interview. “They will bring tanks, cannons, long-range missiles — exactly what we see in hands of Hezbollah in Lebanon, where we have no control whatsoever. If we stop the siege we will see the mirror image of Hezbollah in the Gaza Strip.”



Gain ‘Palestine,’ lose Israel

Right-wing MK in Teaneck lobbies against two-state solution

American Jews who identify themselves as pro-Israel believe they are helping the Jewish state by advocating a two-state solution, but Member of Knesset Aryeh Eldad asserts that they are wrong.

Eldad, a physician who formed the Hatikva faction of the right-wing National Union Party, says that the creation of a Palestinian state within Israel’s borders will bring more turmoil to the Middle East.

At 8 p.m. on Sept. 14, Eldad will be at Teaneck’s Congregation Bnai Yeshurun to discuss what he says are the perils of the Palestinian Authority’s impending attempt to declare a state. His lecture is entitled “Black September: Will the Arab Spring Lead to a Jewish Fall: How Israel is Preparing for the Upcoming Vote on Palestinian Statehood in the United Nations General Assembly.”

The 66th session of the General Assembly convenes a day before Eldad’s Teaneck speech (Sept. 13), and is expected to take up the question of Palestinian statehood on or after Sept. 20.

Yigal Marcus, a Teaneck resident and Bnai Yeshurun member who helped organize the event along with the One Israel Fund, said it is important for American Jews to hear such voices as Eldad’s at this juncture in history.

“Israel is facing its most dangerous time since its establishment,” said Marcus. “The more we can learn about the situation Israel is facing, the more we can help. Eldad’s outlook is unique. He is an intellectual. He is close to many of the towns in Judea and Samaria. He has an insider’s knowledge. Many people in our community are close to and hold the communities of Judea and Samaria close to our hearts. We need to know what we can do to avoid a potentially disastrous situation.”

Often, non-Jewish congressmen and senators are quicker to grasp the dangers of a Palestinian state in Israel than many Jews, says Eldad, who spoke with The Jewish Standard by telephone Tuesday morning.

“I believe that if we will create a Palestinian state in the heartland of Israel, then the next Palestinian election will bring a Hamas state that will bring death to Israel,” Eldad says. He said that the current trend across the globe is “for everything to become more Islamicized….The democratic dream of many naïve people will not come to fruition.”

Eldad argues that the past two decades have demonstrated that the reason peace has eluded Israel is due to Arab violence and Arab refusal to recognize the state of Israel. The creation of a Palestinian state, Eldad says, is unlikely to change this tune. The “war being waged against Israel” by terrorists is not about occupied territories or settlements in Judea and Samaria, he says. “It is against the very existence of the State of Israel.”

While Israel has made concessions for peace, Eldad notes, the Arabs have responded by indoctrinating their children with hatred for Israel and have even named their parks and public buildings after terrorists.

Eldad, who has been called an extremist by some, particularly in the Israeli media, has spent much of his life as a healer. The father of five was professor and chairman of plastic surgery and burns unit at the Hadassah Medical Center Hospital in Jerusalem, where he treated Arabs as well as Jews. Eldad earned worldwide acclaim for his treatment of burns, including the prestigious Evans Award from the American Burns Treatment Association. He was also instrumental in creating the Israeli National Skin Bank, which stores skin for burn victims, as well as for wartime or casualty situations. Among his Arab patients, he says, were those who openly spoke to him about their desire to destroy Israel.

Previously, he was the chief medical officer and a senior commander of the Israel Defense Forces.

Eldad was first elected to Knesset in 2003. These days, he quips, he spends half his time fighting against the creation of a Palestinian state in the west bank and Gaza, and spends the rest of his time fighting corruption.

Bnai Yeshurun is located at 641 West Englewood Avenue in Teaneck.

Page 1 of 1 pages
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31